Name: Spitzer Insurance Agency
Price range: $

Trusted. Local. Independent insurance agency in Indiana.

Spitzer Insurance Agency has the knowledge and expertise to help with your commercial trucking, fleet, and business insurance needs in Indiana.

We’re your one-stop-shop for individuals, personal insurance and business insurance. Start a quote by clicking below or give us a call at 937-280-5777 to start the conversation.

Get InsuranceGet Insurance

Get quotes from multiple insurance companies in Indiana.

Spitzer Insurance Agency has your covered.

We’ve built our insurance agency around understanding what you need and what’s important for your family or business to protect. That’s why we work with a wide range of insurance companies and products in Indiana to meet your specific needs, including customized coverages.

We don’t work for the insurance company, we work for you.

By the Numbers.

In more ways than one, insurance is a numbers game. Spitzer Insurance Agency has the experience and expertise to properly protect your business or family for years to come.

Team Members

Customer Satisfaction

Insurance Companies

Industries Served

Client Testimonials.

4.5 31 reviews

See why families and businesses across Ohio trust Spitzer Insurance Agency for comprehensive insurance protection.

Dennis Williams ★★★★★ a week ago
My wife and I have been shopping for different insurance. I’ve been with State Farm 55 years. You would think being with somebody that long it wouldn’t cost that much for insurance, but farmers prices were extremely less and made it worth … More switching. Over the years we have not made a whole lot of claims. For some reason, I answered the phone and it was Trinity our new agent on the other line and I gave her all the information of what we were paying and what it covered and she came back with a lot better deal. She was patient with me and we told her we would think things over and get back with her which we finally decided to go with farmers and we’re glad that we did. We’re saving substantial amount of money. And being retired that helps out. We both probably only drive A little more than 5000 miles each a year.
Allen Dunlap ★★★★★ 3 weeks ago
10/10 would recommend. They answer the phone and get right on the stuff. Handle all the paperwork. Nice as heck. Personable.Go with these guys. Found me some great prices too.
Jeanette Martin ★★★★★ a month ago
Farmer's was very quick to act when I hit a deer and my car was classified a total loss. No one was injured and the didn't need to be towed. I was on a rental in less than 2 hours. Annie's office called me to see how things … More were going and all the claims agents I dealt with were very kind and explained every step.
TY Lilly ★★★★★ a month ago
Melissa was awesome and a pleasure to work with. She went the extra mile for me and I appreciated that.
Brendan Kuhl ★★★★★ a month ago
Great team. Provided an amazing quote and were willing to modify it to my needs. Best price and great coverage!
Dave Swigonski ★★★★★ 6 months ago
Annie Spitzer was able to offer me new policies for home, auto and umbrella, with the same amount of coverage, for significant yearly savings!

View More Testimonials

Providing customized insurance for commercial trucking, fleets, businesses, and families in Indiana.

…and all other cities throughout Indiana.

Indiana Independent Agent vs The Rest.

Here is a quick comparison of the differences between an independent agency in Indiana like us, and the various other types of companies that are out there:

Features & Services	Captive Agent	Online & 1-800 Companies
Access to multiple companies and wide range of products
Easy switching from company to company without hassle
Unbiased and objective advice	Tries to sell & support only their one company	Tries to sell & support only their one company
Claims assistance and advocacy	Adjusters are often exclusive to the one company	No help: You vs. adjuster
Policy service from the same person you bought from	To call center	You'll likely never talk to the same person twice
When you buy from an independent agent like us, you're supporting local business and your local economy #choicematters #independentagent

Get a quick estimate.

Spitzer Insurance Agency is here to help you find the right coverage for yourself, your family, or business in Ohio. Submit your information below and one of our expert insurance advisors will reach out to you to discuss your insurance options to get you the right policy fast.

"*" indicates required fields

Company

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Contact Name*

First Name Last Name

Phone*

Email*

How it works.

1
Fill out the form.
2
We will go over your options with you.
3

Get the coverage you need.

If you would rather call us to discuss your insurance needs or schedule a time in person, please call us today!

937-280-5777

About Spitzer Insurance Agency.

Insuring Ohio communities with personalized insurance services.

Spitzer Insurance Agency delivers personalized insurance solutions to our clients in Ohio, with offices in both Dayton OH, and Fairfield OH. We are your trusted partners in safeguarding what matters most.

With a comprehensive range of insurance solutions, we’re dedicated to providing peace of mind and financial security. Whether it’s Home Insurance, Car Insurance, Life Insurance, Private Client, or Business Insurance, Spitzer Insurance Agency can determine the perfect plan at an affordable price.

Our experienced team of professionals is committed to tailoring insurance policies that meet your unique needs, offering expert guidance, and exceptional customer service. Discover the protection you deserve with Spitzer Insurance Agency, one-stop insurance destination.

More About UsMore About Us

Office Locations

Happy Clients

Customer Satisfaction